Dinner and a movie

By: Joshua Fidel Feria
November 06, 2017
1215

In an impassioned review of Woody Allen’s magnum opus, ‘Hannah and Her Sisters’ (1986), Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic Roger Ebert wrote the following passage: “We try to organize our lives according to what we have read and learned and believed in, but our plans are lost in a tumult of emotion.”

Mang Roger, as I like to call him, had always been among my favorite writers, not merely because he penned reviews I more often than not agreed with, but because he unfailingly, even for the films he’d come to revile, wrote with such an evocation of genuine feeling.

On a whim, as “Hannah and Her Sisters” stands by and large a personal favorite, I recounted this passage to a girl who shall herein be named, only for the purposes of this column, Revolution.

I had imagined, owing to the minor detail of her being a film major, that she would share the same enthusiasm I had for such poignant writing about the movies. The reputation of the university she attends preceded her, and the childish, sweeping generalizations I’d made in my head were inclusive of, but not limited to, her having an encyclopedic knowledge of everything there was ever to know about the movies.

“Naturally,” she replied, brimming with a snark I had, in the past couple of dinner-dates, grown accustomed to.

You see, in an emotional rambling she had been graceful enough to withstand quietly, I had once been all too vocal about my fanaticism over Mr. Allen’s oeuvre.

As it turns out, she didn’t care much for it. Revolution was adamant; she maintained that one cannot simply compartmentalize one’s perceptions about the art and the artist. I conceded, again owing to the fact that whatever came out of her highly-educated smart-mouth, I would immediately perceive as gospel. As charming as ‘Annie Hall’ was, she explained, the allegations against Mr. Allen--that of molesting his own (now formerly) adopted a child--is too glaring a dent in the man’s person to simply sweep under the rug.

My painstaking admission was that I had done my share of overlooking.

For instance, just this September, comedian Louis C.K., another artist whose work across platforms (in television, the nihilistic ‘Louie’ and the morose ‘Horace and Pete’) and stand-up comedy specials I have admired for years, has been met with disturbing allegations of sexual misconduct himself. Particularly, as per the accusations of actress Roseanne Barr, C.K. would lock himself in a room with fellow comics and pleasure himself—presumably in full view of his captives.

“So who do you like, then?” I inquired sheepishly. “Strictly the morally upstanding ones?”

“Chis Marker,” Revolution replied gamely. “I like his film essays, as well as his documentaries. Also, kasi socialist siya.”

Hurriedly, I made as if I was checking my phone, so as to hide the fact that I had begun looking up who the hell Chris Marker was. As it happens, Mr. Marker’s record is of relative purity (Marker was a recluse) compared to that of Woody Allen’s widely-debated private life.

This, I would have to believe, is the gamble we as gentle spectators, must make with art and its appreciation. The conundrum is made apparent when you go beyond the mere knowledge of the work, and subsequently delve deeper into the person who had the audacity to place oneself, as well as the product of his consciousness, at the mercy of public scrutiny.

To wit, in writing for BBC Culture, art critic Fisun Guner wrote the following in relation to the contentious subject of separating the art and the artist: “...It’s never just about the work. What we do when we celebrate an artist is often to bolster the myth of their life.”

“We do this with Caravaggio exactly because we’re fascinated by his earthy and seductive ‘bad boy’ image,” Guner added in conclusion.” That roughness and that sexuality make him feel alive to us and incredibly modern, as alive as the figures in his paintings. And we do this with Oscar Wilde, who we celebrate today for exactly those things that ensured his condemnation in life.”

She and I finally came to an agreement; this line of thinking was the most logical.

By the evening’s conclusion, however, after I had chivalrously accompanied her back to the steps of Maskom, I had won myself a small victory. My raving over the film (and, I guess, Roger Ebert’s too) had apparently piqued much of her interest. As of writing, upon a quick perusal of Revolution’s hard drive, there laid in all its glory, is a folder plainly named as follows: “Hannah and Her Sisters (1986)”.

(First published on The LANCE's September Issue)

Comments

  1. COA: Donations for Typhoon Ulysses Victims found Rotten and Undistributed
  2. Philippines, Vulnerable to Rising Global Temperatures
  3. Knights bite the dust, succumbs to San Beda
  4. Filipino authors, books withstand Red-Tagging remarks VS KWF
  5. Sen. Hontiveros seeks to plumb the P7B "questionable releases" of CHED's UniFAST
  6. Letran celebrates Hybrid Binyag Arriba for Senior High School
  7. COA Reports on the Overpriced 39,583 Laptops Units DepEd Procured
  8. Senate Steps in, Files Resolution to solve Gilas Woes
  9. Students and RSOs Hardwork Pays Off in the Collegiate Orientation and Gaward Arriba 2022
  10. Knights fall to neighbors Pirates, record first loss
  11. Academic Year 2022-2023, Commences with Three Subsequent Annual Events
  12. Letranites Creativity and Passion Mirrors RSOs booths in the 2022 Org Fair
  13. Caralipio, Paraiso lift Knights past Tamaraws in FilOil EcoOil Preseason
  14. First Year CBAA Students, Welcomed to the Colegio with Binyag Arriba Day 2
  15. Colegio welcomes CLAS, COED, CEIT freshmen for Binyag Arriba Day 1
  16. Letran falters to UST, Gets Eliminated from Playoff Contention
  17. Wangs-Letran Bows To Baste, Drops Their Third in a Row
  18. Monkeypox detected in PH, Senate marks DOH Chief as 'urgent'
  19. Vape Law lapses into Law
  20. Wangs-Letran Stung by CEU Scorpions with Second Straight Loss
  21. Kobe Monje powers Letran to first FilOil Preseason Cup Win
  22. The New Slate of Officials for the 19th Congress of the Philippines
  23. Knights succumb to Green Archers in D-League
  24. The Trial Classes for the Elementary, Junior High School, and Senior High School of Letran: A Testament
  25. Ferdinand Marcos Jr. delivers his first SONA at the newly renovated Batasang Pambansa
  26. Shooting in Ateneo de Manila University Results into 3 Deaths and Several Injuries
  27. Teatro de Letran’s “Piladelpiya, Hirrr Ay Kammm!!!” Wows Teatro Europa’s Third Edition Launch; Letran Filipiniana Dance Company Opening, a Dazzling Comeback Performance.
  28. The Letran Let’s Flex Hyflex Program: The Start of Modern Innovative Education
  29. Wangs-Letran Outguns Gutsy Marinerong Pilipino, Gains solo Lead in D-League
  30. Letran Survives Gritty AMA Scare to Get 2nd Straight D-League Win
  31. Cyberknights Grab First Win in CCE, Goes 1-3
  32. Letran Gets Swept By San Sebastian, Officially Ends Season 97 Campaign
  33. Former CBCP President, Archbishop Lagdameo, dies at 81
  34. Sangalang, Paraiso, Caralipio provide championship composure as Letran overcomes pesky St. Clare
  35. Knights unveil roster for PBA D-League
  36. Letran stuns Mapua, Improves to 2-6
  37. Esports: Letran bows to Arellano and CSB in MLBB at the Collegiate Center for Esports Competition
  38. Lady Knights Yield to Lady Generals
  39. A Fight Against Poverty: Launching of Angat Buhay NGO
  40. President Ferdinand Romualdez Marcos Jr.; Now on the Highest Seat of the Nation
  41. First woman-elect Lacuna takes oath as the 28th Mayor of Manila
  42. “It’s not a signal for me to stop, but to keep on going.”: NBA Dream still alive for Kai Sotto even after Draft Snub
  43. Letran bows to Lyceum; Drops to 1-4
  44. Lady Knights Escape San Beda in Five Set Thriller; Finally Enters Winning Column
  45. Knights sweep Cardinals, cops 19th NCAA title
  46. Letran Completes Comeback Over Mapua to Take Game One
  47. Still in Shining Armor: Letran Escaped The Altas’ Scare, Charges to the NCAA 97 Finals With an Unblemished Record.
  48. Letran Escapes Arch-rivals, Finishes Elimination Round With A Clean Sweep
  49. Elite Eight: Abando, Paraiso Lead Knights to Gritty Win Against Golden Stags, Secures Final Four Slot.
  50. Knights Thrash Bombers, Extending Their Unbeaten Streak to 7-0.  
  51. A Look Into Ping Lacson
  52. Letran Escapes Lyceum, Secures Fifth Straight Win of the Season
  53. Knights Continue Hot Streak, Trounces Mapua
  54. Letran Triumphs Over Perpetual, Abando Records Career Game
  55. Letran Dominates Arellano, gets 2nd Straight Win
  56. Letran Charges Back, Edges Benilde in NCAA ‘97 Opener
  57. Rewriting OPM: The P-pop Takeover
  58. Filipino Humor and Pinoy Comedy Films: A Sacrosanct Relationship
  59. The Unfaltering Voice of the Press
  60. To Get The Fire Back
  61. Pearl's Pride and Glory: First Philippine Republic Day
  62. CHED and DOH Visit Letran In Preparation For NCAA Bubble, Colegio Now Approved For Training
  63. Stand-up Comedy Culture with The KoolPals
  64. LCES, Finally an Official Alliance of AcadArena
  65. To The Unsung Heroes in Our Screens
  66. Tokyo 2021: Looking back and moving forward
  67. Exhibiting ‘Resiliency and Creativity’: NCAA Season 96 to kick off on June 13
  68. NCAA ‘Special’ Season 96 to push through with online sporting events in May
  69. Letran alumnus to send Colegio’s 400th Anniversary score and lyrics to the moon
  70. LOOKBACK: A glimpse of Letran’s Yellow Brick Road of Sports in 2020
  71. Two bullets each
  72. DENR awards Colegio with Gawad Maparaan
  73. Letran conducts webinar on violence against women
  74. The Greatest Reset
  75. Lloyd Cadena: More than a vlogger
  76. Long live the King!
  77. Former Tigers Paraiso, Bataller set to become new members of the Knights
  78. Killing our heroes
  79. Students urge suspension of online classes despite memo from VPAA
  80. Philippines under state of calamity due to COVID-19
  81. NCAA Season 95 suspended indefinitely
  82. Letranites express dismay over Paskong Arriba
  83. Quadricentennial Year 4 ends with a double celebration
  84. Letran dethrones San Beda, claims 18th title
  85. Dugong Arriba: Kilalanin ang ating Rektor